8 Comments
User's avatar
Edward's avatar

To be fair, you and I along with everyone else alive is the result of winning the sperm Olympics. The odds of getting to the uterus end zone is slim to none. Any non zero probability of getting to Mars and extending our collective existence is worth a shot.

That said, I do agree that it should be further down the list of humanity's priorities. Coincidently you're not the first person that has described a planet as a life boat. I watched a TED Talk years ago and the lady giving the talk said "Making Mars our backup planet is like the captain of the Titanic telling us the party is on the life boat".

Bob's avatar

Thanks, Ed, for weighing in. Unfortunately, I disagree strongly with pretty much every claim you make.

There is no sperm Olympics. If you flip a coin and it comes up tails, it didn't "overcome the odds" to win. It was either going to be heads or tails. It was tails. Flip it again and get a different result. Same sperm, different day — almost certainly a different winner. The sperm just swim. It's what they do. It's not like one of them is thinking, "Oh, no! Bob's ahead of me. Must. Swim. Harder." They are not "competing" in the sense that athletes do.

And there is no relationship between coitus and creating a livable and sustainable habitat for humans on Mars anyway, except that if we attempt the latter, we definitely will get fucked. It's an absurd analogy. Attempting to go to Mars will not help to extend our existence; it will help to end it. We will be wasting time, effort, and resources on a pipe dream while needs on Earth go unmet. But worse, that pipe dream provides an escape hatch to allow dreamers to avoid acting because "we're going to Mars".

But when attempting to defend the indefensible, false analogies abound. My favorite was the person who compared "colonizing" (he meant settling) Mars to the "colonization" (he meant conquest) of the "Americas". Because sailing a few thousand miles across an ocean through temperate breathable air to a land flush with everything humans need to survive and flourish is exactly like traveling through high radiation and vacuum for 50+ million kilometers to try to make a go in a frozen, airless environment entirely inhospitable to any kind of life, right? There is no analogy here.

These false analogies and apparent compromises suggesting that we move Mars "further down the list of humanity's priorities" are really just desperate efforts to keep the pipe dream alive. Who gets to decide this anyway? Do the billion or so hungry children in "underdeveloped" countries get a vote, or just superrich white Americans?

The best thing we can do is go all in on Earth. Survival or bust. That you are having such a hard time letting go of the Mars dream suggests that your belief in it is emotional, not rational. Understandable, but we no longer have time for dreaming. It's do or die. Literally.

But I'm not trying to persuade you. This response is for the bystanders whose minds are still open. I know that nothing will change the minds of the science-fantasy folks because their belief is not rational, but emotional. Facts don't matter at all. There will never be enough of them to change the minds (or behavior) of those whose belief is essentially a religion rather than a carefully reasoned argument.

Edward's avatar

Fair point on the sperm Olympics analogy.

FWIW I'm open minded as far as the whole Mars exploration goes. It's highly unlikely that I'll live long enough to see humans successfully terraform Mars and make it habitable. And even if by some miraculous feat it did come true, I have no intention of going to another planet. Also Maciej Cegłowski agrees with you: https://idlewords.com/2023/1/why_not_mars.htm.

From reading some of your other posts it seems like a rough summary of your position is: Shit is FUBAR, tech is becoming more and more of a net-negative, what we need is maturity, mass adoption of zero-waste lifestyle and redistribution of wealth.

Where we disagree is, while there are many downsides to technology I think tech needs to be part of the solution. The things you've mentioned aren't enough to get us out of this mess.

For example, The Ocean Cleanup project is developing technology to clean up the plastics floating in the ocean. Obviously effort is required by everyone to mitigate the dumping of plastics in the ocean in the first place but better tech used to clean up existing waste will help.

Several years ago I came across this video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pz9zl8t3UPU. Biggest takeaway from it for me was phosphorous is essential for life and is a finite resource. Unlike oil and fossil fuels, there are no alternatives. Therefore it's vital that people are trying to engineer more efficient plants to use less of it.

Off the top of my head those are some of the examples that I could think of.

Bob's avatar

The issue is, Ed, that all these essays, videos, etc. are biased. They beg the question by starting with what you claim here with zero evidence to back it up: namely, that we must have tech to survive.

The rebuttal to that is, hmm, 250,000 years of low tech survival. It is a common rationalization made by technophiles that we need X to fix the problem that X caused. But no explanation of how that will work as more X has always, without exception, resulted in exacerbating the problem.

And all of these arguments avoid admitting the many conditions that they take for granted. For example, that we will continue to manufacture plastics. That we will continue to grossly overpopulate the Earth with eight-plus billion humans. That nature needs our help to clean up our mess (it doesn't).

But the biggest problem in all this is the incredibly hubristic and narcissistic assumption of dominion: that the Earth exists to be exploited by homo sapiens. The argument is not about to whom the Earth belongs: that much is assumed. That we have displaced virtually every other species on Earth and have eliminated all the wilderness (even the word reveals our mindset) is the truth that cannot be told.

What right do we have to control all of the Earth's surface and exploit it for our benefit? What right do we have to "conquer" the stars? Is this not the imperial mindset writ large? Is it not anti-nature? In fact, it is the dogma of the technophile religion (and several other religions as well): this is our planet and even our galaxy (see Star Trek, etc.) to do with as we wish.

But don't worry. Nothing I say is going to change a thing. We will return to the Pleistocene "model" whether we like it or not — if we survive at all. Nature will see to it. And that is as certain as that the sun will rise again tomorrow. I'm just positioning myself to say "I told you so".

Edward's avatar

It seems that you've shifted from anti tech to a more anti human perspective. We'll just have to agree to disagree if you believe that human intelligence, and the technological advances that have come from it are bad for the planet, therefore the Earth and its other inhabitants are better off without us.

We're all doomed to die. That much is guaranteed. Yes it's just a matter of time before we return to the Pleistocene "model", but your position seems kind of pointless. If there was a human-level extinction event tomorrow I doubt anyone would care you told them so beforehand tbf.

That said every person has a right to prolong their existence (it's literally in our DNA) and the continued collective existence of humanity in general. At the end of the day we're living creatures. Most living creatures are prolonging their existence at the expense of other species. I disagree that when we do it it's unnatural and goes against nature fundamentally speaking. In terms of you questioning our right to control all of the Earth's surface and exploit it, like it or not we are the stewards of life on this planet. Given that we haven't yet found life outside of Earth, this extends to life in the universe (at least for now). We don't have a right to exploit, but we do have responsibility to intervene. Our intelligence gives us the ability to have a more sophisticated ethical framework than "Kill or be killed" so we have more agency.

I don't know if you remember this, but when you invited me to your place, we spoke about your cat Pris and I also showed you a picture of my cat on my phone. Now an argument can be made that breeding cats into a well mannered Ragdolls like Pris is unnatural and goes against Darwinian natural selection. Cats and dogs also eat meat so systematically killing of other animals is required to sustain the lives of so many pets. Should we release all the cats and dogs back into the wild and let nature run it's course? Kill the majority of pets and introduce the rest back into nature? Personally I'd rather see the cost of lab meat get decreased with technological advances so that we can have indoor cats and not purposely have to create any unnecessary animal suffering. Same goes for ourselves. Maybe lab meat will have unintended consequences but as a meat eater myself I'm definitely for being able to have our meat cakes and eat it too.

I see several problems with your argument to go back to pre-industrial (I'm assuming this is how far back you want us to go technologically speaking) life and just let nature run its course.

1. It's unrealistic. Very few people will buy into this.

2. You're underestimating how shit life was in the past. The vast majority of people were commoners and peasants, doing mundane manual work just to survive. I've been to the forbidden city in Beijing, part of the tour we saw the emperor's living quarters. It was just some dark and dank little room. Most people in the developed world have access to things that past emperors/kings could only dream of. You're probably taking basic things like warm tap water, electrical lights for granted. People died from infections from wounds all the time.

It is true that we are winning at the game of life too much. There are many species that have become the losers to our gains and have died out. This is not sustainable in the long run and our "wins" will ultimately cause us to become extinct as well. Therefore some drastic changes need to take place. As politically incorrect as this sounds I want there to be an international one child policy. Forced sterilisation is harsh, obviously but it's a lesser of the two evils compared to the alternative... Also international treaties on bioengineering and, AI development should be in place too. I'm definitely receptive towards a simple living life-style. I've been looking at ways I can reduce waste. I just think there are better ways than anarcho-primitivism to solve the problems we're facing. I'd much rather vote for policies that'll buy us more time and have civilization transition into a anarcho-techno society where everyone can live in a comfortable self-sustaining homes.